NiborBobbin's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Nova]

So lets start from the top:

WRONG BASS DRUM. Make it harder, louder but not overpowered. That way you can emphasise the guitar. Because of that I feel that the song really was wack.

Your guitar is OK at times and not to well at others. For example, the intro was excellent (really had a smile on me). But then the weak drums come in and there was not backing to the main melody so it was very bland. Then you have your headbang section at 52 seconds but it was really lacking.

Check out a song called agalloch - limbs. You may find it good inspiration. This is because your section at 1:08 had a similar sound.

There is much I would change but otherwise you are really not that far off!
For now, work on your drums and think about how to complement your main guitar properly with harmonies.

mastercloak responds:

Dude, this is awesome. Thanks a ton for the constructive criticism. I'll definitely heed your advice.

[It's Snowing]

Constant arpegio on the harp ruined the intro. Try using more of a strum from low to high quickly and only on the beat every so often to make a more dramatic sound.

Choir, well done.
Sleigh bells. Again, nice!
Flute, I would have used a different instrument. Piccolo I think would have done better.
The church bells where very nice

As the song progressed you really outdid yourself which is why I feel that you need to change the harps.

All in all, it was a lovely song

LawnReality responds:

Thanks for the advice about the harp, and the flute! I'll keep it in mind for future tracks. I'm glad that they didn't stop you from enjoying the song too much. :)

[There Is Hope]

Ok. So lets begin with the review.

Your background drums are too loud. But as the song progressed it sounded very nice. Almost like avatar.

Your melody is OK and builds well. But you are not taking advantage of the higher notes. Bring in some drama to the high end of the scale instead of relying too much on the lower end. This is what horns and oboes are good at.

1:55 that was cheeky with the drop and I very much liked it.

1:57 your use of the horns. Well done

I think your strings are too powerful at times but that is a preference as opposed to a requirement. How to improve? Just bring in more drama (complicated melodies). Layer that with more harmonics and you are done.

Earel responds:

Thank you :)

I take in consideration everything you said

[Cosmic Fire]

The song lacked the typical harmonies of a song where you would have lower notes acompany the higher notes. Because of this the song sounded more flat in placed (for example: 0:15 and 0:22). The drums where fantastic for this song (being video game).

I think what makes this difficult to use in a game is how the e-pianos and main synth are very high pitch making it difficult to concentrate on the game. Its amazing how much damage can be done with high pitch high frequency bells and synths.

All in all I would change the main synth to be more sawtooth based (but a mega drive brass could do well there). At the same time I would add extra bass layers to really bring out the lower end of the song and make this track complete.

DanJohansen responds:

''The song lacked the typical harmonies of a song where you would have lower notes acompany the higher notes'' - This to me sounds like formula working something I am against and I don't really like following set ways when making instruments work together.

I can understand how the high pitches can annoy some people, I don't have against tracks that has it personally, I kind of dig that moment of holy shit when it happens in tunes, but if it was places within a game and the SFX used interfered with each other, I think toning down the high pitch with EQ or a sound change would be in place. I would still want the OST released with this version in such a case though.

Glad you enjoyed it though!

[Steven Universe - Stronger Than You (Flaytic Remix)]

First thing, not techno.

Secondly, you have talent but I feel that the over use of gliding synths ruins the intro slightly.
But when I hear the lyrics, wow. I am very VERY impressed. This song is too fast to enjoy but at the same time it is very nice and I can tell that alot of work has gone into this.

Chord progressions, typical minor to major but hey I use that too so....

I notice that you also wobble the frequency of the synths at times, dont unless its the last note on a loop. Otherwise it can sound out of place.

I am a harsh reviewer who has high standards, so from me, 4/5. Well done and keep up the work!

Flaytic responds:

Well first off, techno was the closest of the given genres this was closest to.

Yeah I, too, feel like I overuse the vibrato sometimes. Its a bad habit I'm trying to break.

Being given a 4/5 from a harsh reviewer is enough of a compliment to me :D Thanks for you review!